Log in

View Full Version : Finally, new hope for Symbian and S60



Ben
24th June 2008, 11:29 AM
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/06/24/symbian_foundation/

Nokia grabs control of Symbian - then gives it away


Nokia has bought up the bits of Symbian it didn't already own and is chucking the OS into an open-source foundation along with the S60 UI layer, accompanied by Sony Ericsson and DoCoMo, who are throwing in UIQ and MOAP(S) respectively.

Symbian has always been the underlying OS allowing companies to develop different graphical layers on top in much the same way that Windows (
The differences between the UIs were becoming increasingly blurred, with developments such as S60 adding touch-control and UIQ 3 offering penless interaction, and now all three of them are to be combined into a single UI layer and given away royalty-free to Symbian Foundation members.

Those members will have to cough up at least $1,500 a year, but that's chicken feed to companies such as AT&T and Vodafone, which have come on board to endorse the more open Symbian platform.

This does remove at a stroke the principle advantage of Google's Android: the code being free. But it also removes a significant source of revenue for Nokia, which is paying €264m for the privilege of being able to give away its software.

The formal announcement from Symbian is due in an hour or so, and more details should emerge then. We'll certainly be taking a more comprehensive look at what Nokia has in mind later today, and how the company intends to make any money in the coming decade or two.
It's a bold and expensive move by Nokia, signalling, perhaps, that the Mobile OS wars have finally begun. I think the new arrangement offers the best hope for Symbian to become a viable OS on a wide range of devices going forward, and may encourage other partners to hop on board.

gorilla
24th June 2008, 04:42 PM
It's been a while since I've posted, so apologises (too busy reading whatleys tweets!)

So, open source symbian? I think this has to be a good move, if for no other reason than to ignite some mobile OS development and to offer up some viable competition to apple and google.
I wonder though, what will the future be for software developers who charge for their products? Will there be so many free apps available that commercial ventures will ultimately fail? Will, for example, mozilla step into the mobile platform (as they have indicated (http://wiki.mozilla.org/Mobile) already) and take on more open source projects? The time is coming when the mobile platform will decide who succeeds in the online environment. Why else would google devise android and apple release the iphone (which will harm their ipod sales...eventually)?
Apple's app store, Androids upcoming platform and now open source symbian, where does windows mobile fit in? Let us not forget that microsoft are still a big player in the mobile world and will no doubt be fighting back with some feature packed phone that doesn't quite work all of the time ;-)

Ben
24th June 2008, 07:07 PM
The Register has an article which is less optimistic (http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/06/24/andrew_on_symbian/) about the future of Symbian. The writer seems to think that Nokia's 100% ownership of the OS makes it unattractive to other companies, who wont want to push anything that belongs to the market leader.

So, perhaps there's hope for Android yet as a software-only player in the mobile phone world against the muscle of Microsoft and its mobile crapware.

But maybe Nokia doesn't care about third parties using Symbian anyway. Maybe what it really wants is full control of the OS and hardware, a la Apple, and the 'open source' part of the announcement is purely to strike a blow to Android given the recent announcement of delays.