Jon3G
27th April 2005, 10:10 AM
By Andrew Orlowski in San Francisco
Published Tuesday 26th April 2005 16:52 GMT
A French appeals court has ruled that movie companies must remove the copy protection from DVDs, and castigated them for inadequately labeling copy-protected movies.
The Paris court reversed an earlier ruling in favor of Le Studio Canal and Films Alain Sarde against consumer group UFC-Que Chosir, reports Afterdawn. The lobby group took up the case of a DVD owner who discovered he was unable to make a copy of the David Lynch movie Mulholland Drive to play on a video recorder. This violated the basic rights the DVD owner had to make copies in a family context, the court ruled.
The court also ruled that the labeling was inadequate. A higher appeals court may yet overrule the decision, and rights holders may decide to invoke the European Copyright Directive in France, which outlaws machinery that enables such 'circumvention' of locked media.®
Related stories
Movie industry settles DVD chips case
Congress moots mandatory DRM scheme
Cryptographers to Hollywood: prepare to fail on DRM
The Cell Chip - how will MS and Intel face the music?
IT hardware makers back EU patent directive
Hollywood drops DVD lawsuit
US inspired copyright laws set to sweep the globe for fun and profit
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/04/26/french_drm_non/
Published Tuesday 26th April 2005 16:52 GMT
A French appeals court has ruled that movie companies must remove the copy protection from DVDs, and castigated them for inadequately labeling copy-protected movies.
The Paris court reversed an earlier ruling in favor of Le Studio Canal and Films Alain Sarde against consumer group UFC-Que Chosir, reports Afterdawn. The lobby group took up the case of a DVD owner who discovered he was unable to make a copy of the David Lynch movie Mulholland Drive to play on a video recorder. This violated the basic rights the DVD owner had to make copies in a family context, the court ruled.
The court also ruled that the labeling was inadequate. A higher appeals court may yet overrule the decision, and rights holders may decide to invoke the European Copyright Directive in France, which outlaws machinery that enables such 'circumvention' of locked media.®
Related stories
Movie industry settles DVD chips case
Congress moots mandatory DRM scheme
Cryptographers to Hollywood: prepare to fail on DRM
The Cell Chip - how will MS and Intel face the music?
IT hardware makers back EU patent directive
Hollywood drops DVD lawsuit
US inspired copyright laws set to sweep the globe for fun and profit
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/04/26/french_drm_non/