Log in

View Full Version : Which reports 33% fault rate on 3 handsets



3GScottishUser
4th August 2005, 02:10 PM
From Which Website (04/08/2005):
One in seven mobile phones goes wrong within a year and getting retailers to put problems right isn't easy, says Which?

According to Which? findings, at least two million of the 18 million mobile phones sold in the UK last year could have been faulty. Handsets are most likely to go wrong during the first six months.

To help people affected who aren't getting any joy from their retailer Which? has set up a model complaint letter.

The 3 network has the worst record for faults - around one in three mobiles on this network developed a problem within 12 months.

This may be because the brand-new, hi-tech products offered by 3 are prone to teething problems.

Networks offering more of the longer-established models in their ranges, such as Virgin and Tesco, fare better for handset reliability.

Some handset brands themselves have more problems than others. Motorola and Sony Ericsson handsets were the most likely to go wrong; about a fifth of owners reported faults.

Nokia and Samsung were the most reliable, although about one in ten users still had faulty phones.

To make it worse, people are finding it difficult to get problems put right. By law, if a phone develops a fault within six months and the shop can't show it was the customer's fault, the shop must sort out the problem.

However, over a quarter of people surveyed said they were unhappy with the way their mobile phone problem was handled.

Which? editor Malcolm Coles says:

'A one-in-seven chance your phone's going to develop a fault is way too high. Not only that, but retailers who should be bending over backwards to help customers who've already suffered the inconvenience of a fault aren't giving people the help they need when they complain.'

http://trial.which.co.uk/audio_visual_equipment.php?m_id=80&source_code=j8uw04

MORPH
4th August 2005, 10:30 PM
In regards to Nokia, from what I'm aware, they pretty much have a lifetime guarantee, if they develop a fault which isn't the customers fault. I've taken a 5 year old handset to a Nokia service centre before now, and got it repaired for free after it developed a software fault.

Ben
5th August 2005, 12:40 AM
Good to see Nokia as one of the better fairing brands. Nokia recently extended their warranty to two years which can only be a sign of their commitment to quality.

Edit: As this is posted in the Three area, here are the official comments from Three for you to make your own decision from. link (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/4745205.stm)

"Rachel Channing from 3 told the BBC News website that it was unrealistic to try and compare 3G technology, which is complex and new, to GSM technology.

Downloading full-length music videos, making video calls and so on is relatively novel for many people, so there was more chance of things going wrong.

She also criticised the sample size of the survey.

"The sample they picked out was only 50 customers. We have three million. It was only 16 who had experienced problems, so we don't think it is a representative sample," she said.

She added that the problems reported related to its oldest 3G handset model, released about two years ago.

"The technology is evolving so rapidly and the performance as you release them improves every time.

"Those handsets have been superseded by ones that perform much better on the network," she said."

FAULT REPORTS WITHIN YEAR OF PURCHASE
3 - 32%
Orange - 16%
T-Mobile - 15%
Vodafone - 15%
BT Mobile - 14%
02 - 13%
Virgin - 8%
Tesco - 4%
Source: Which? survey

bsrjl1
5th August 2005, 07:30 AM
Be interesting to see what the fault rates were for 3G handsets only on other networks - make it more of a fair comparisson?

3GScottishUser
5th August 2005, 09:04 AM
I suspect they will be much lower as much of the blame will be attributable to the known issues with NEC and LG kit that is exclusive to 3.

Ben
5th August 2005, 11:18 AM
Possibly, but the Z1010 and 6630 wouldn't make pretty reading for Orange.

3GScottishUser
5th August 2005, 12:31 PM
"Possibly, but the Z1010 and 6630 wouldn't make pretty reading for Orange."

Indeed but they did'nt exactly flood the market with them, in fact the Z1010 was only sold for a very limited period.